The Best Creamy Dill Red Skin Potato Salad

When I was at my pretty and charming, blue-eyed niece’s graduation party I had gotten myself a nice juicy hamburger with all the fixings I like and a small side of baked beans just before I walked over to the table that had all of the side dishes including what I had made, The Best Creamy Dill Red Skin Potato Salad or should I say what was left of it! There had to be a spoonful left! I heard someone asking my friend “Who brought potato salad?”

The Best Creamy Dill Potato Salad

The whole dang container with FIVE pounds of red skin potatoes was GONE! It was the only food that was gone already. Word travels FAST! So, then came the requests for the recipe. Would ya’ll let me eat first? LOL!

The problem with store-bought, and even some homemade, potato salads is hard potatoes. But, if you let them cook too long, they get mushy. They they look a little like mashed potatoes. Well, you want them to be soft little cubes of dill-flavored potatoes!

This recipe uses steamed potatoes to give it the silky, soft texture from perfectly cooked potatoes. A creamy dill red skin potato salad will vanish from your table in no time.  Now, get the burgers and dogs ready. I mean hot dogs!

A potato salad with whole, soft potatoes really tastes best. Sometimes, when potatoes are overcooked, they break open in the pot and the water penetrates them making them mushy. However, steaming the potatoes avoids mushy potatoes.

I like using the red skin potatoes not only for their great flavor but, I don’t like spending the time peeling cooked potatoes and burning my fingers. I’m sure you don’t either. In addition, the potato peels are packed full of vitamins.

How to Make The Best Creamy Dill Red Skin Potato Salad in 3 Steps!

1. First, in a large stock pot with steamer insert on high heat, steam the potatoes whole (5 lbs takes about 50 min- remove smaller potatoes as they will cook faster. Let cool. Cut into 1 inch pieces leaving skin on but, discard skin that peels off easily while cutting.
2. Then, in a medium bowl, mix mayonnaise, dill pickle brine, mustard, vinegar, sugar, salt, pepper, and garlic.
3. Finally, in a very large bowl, add cut potatoes, dill, chopped celery, eggs, and mayo mixture. Mix well and store in a covered container for several hours or overnight (is best.) Garnish with celery leaves.

chopped eggs, celery and scallions

Red Potatoes with Dill

Mayo mixture- mayo, ground mustard, sugar, salt, pepper, vinegar

It is so easy to make this creamy dill red skin potato salad once you get perfectly cooked potatoes. If you’ve never made potato salad by steaming the potatoes, give it a try. Just make sure you check the readiness of the potatoes because, obviously the smaller ones will cook faster.

Remove those and allow them to cool before cutting.

The Best Creamy Red Skin Dill Potato Salad

I also like using Hellmann’s  mayonnaise because I think it is the best! Dill Pickle brine is great to use for potato or macaroni salad to give it flavor so, don’t omit this step but, if you don’t have pickle brine, it will still be a great potato salad nonetheless.

When you need a great potato salad recipe, try the best creamy red skin dill potato salad recipe and watch it disappear.

Your guests will love eating a creamy dill potato salad and go back for seconds. Be the one at the BBQ who made the best potato salad.

What Do I Serve with Potato Salad?

Flavorful Grilled Lemon Rosemary Chicken

Slow Cooker Shredded Italian Pork Sandwiches

Grilled Asian Hoisin Beef Kabobs

How Long Can Potato Salad Sit Out?

It depends on the room temperature. If it’s in cool air conditioning, it can stay out for a couple of hours. Then, move it to the refrigerator. If you are serving it outside, make sure the bowl filled with Macaroni Salad is sitting on a bigger bowl of ice cubes and covered in plastic wrap. Because it has eggs and mayonnaise, it is perishable and can cause illness when bacteria grows. You don’t want harmful bacteria so, better to be safe.

Pin this recipe and sign up to join our newsletter at the bottom of this post to get more free recipes and useful printables!

More from No Plate Like Home:

Deviled Egg Macaroni Salad

I took this recipe to Meal Plan Monday #138.

Print

The Best Creamy Dill Potato Salad

Prep Time

15 mins

Cook Time

45 mins

 

The Best Creamy Dill Potato Salad using steamed potatoes to get a creamy potato consistency.

Course: Side Dish

Cuisine: American

Keyword: dill potato salad, potato salad, red skin potato salad

Servings: 16 Servings

Ingredients

• 5 lb. red potatoes washed with skin on
• 3 cups of Hellmann's mayonaise
• 1 cup of chopped celery
• 6 boiled eggs chopped
• 2 scallions chopped
• 1 1/2 tbsp of dill pickle or Spanish olive brine
• 1 1/2 tbsp ground mustard
• 1 tbsp apple cider vinegar
• 1 tbsp sugar
• 1 tsp dried dill
• 1 tsp salt or more to taste
• 1/2 tsp freshly cracked black pepper
• 1/2 tsp garlic powder

Instructions

1. In a large stock pot with steamer insert on high heat, steam the potatoes whole (5 lbs takes about 50 min- remove smaller potatoes as they will cook faster. Let cool. Cut into 1 inch pieces leaving skin on but, discard skin that peels off easily while cutting.

2. In a medium bowl, mix mayonnaise, dill pickle brine, mustard, vinegar, sugar, salt, pepper, and garlic.

3. In a very large bowl, add cut potatoes, dill, chopped celery, eggs, and mayo mixture. Mix well and store in a covered container for several hours or overnight (is best.) Garnish with celery leaves.

Recipe Notes

If you are limited with time, you may boil potatoes for 30 minutes or so depending upon the size of the potatoes. When a fork comes out rather easily, the potatoes are done. Do not overcook or they will get mushy.