A mint julep is a classic southern cocktail celebrated at the Kentucky Derby each year but, which is the best bourbon for mint julep? Let’s explore the possibilities and I’ll give you my easy three-ingredient recipe too!

Best Bourbon for Mint Julep

When it comes to classic cocktails, few can rival the refreshing allure of the classic mint julep. Originating in the American South, this iconic drink is synonymous with leisurely hot summer afternoons and Southern hospitality.

The Mint Julep is a bourbon cocktail best known for being the signature drink of the Kentucky Derby where it’s rumored that over 100,00 mint juleps are served to a lot of people (thirsty people that is) at any derby weekend at Churchill Downs Racetrack in Louisville, Kentucky.

Therefore, mint julep cocktails are a must for a Kentucky Derby party along with some great appetizers and my Kentucky Derby Pie Bars that are made with chocolate chips, crunchy pecans and brown sugar.

It’s such a delicious drink that you shouldn’t only have it for the Kentucky Derby. It’s great to drink any time.

Disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I’ll receive a small commission but, the price you pay is the same.

At the heart of this concoction lies good bourbon, a spirit cherished for its depth of flavor and versatility. Choosing a suitable bourbon to your liking is the key to making the perfect mint julep because the bourbon is the main ingredient.

Therefore, it’s flavoring will be the spotlight.

But not all bourbons are the same. It’s best to use a high-quality bourbon that you enjoy. A slightly higher-proof bourbon (mid-80s to 90 proof) will keep the crushed ice from diluting the cocktail too quickly, especially if it’s hot outside!

I love using mint leaves in some of my cocktails. It adds a fresh, clean taste and pairs well with some spirits such as bourbon, rum and vodka. This is evidenced in my Limoncello Moscow Mules and Limoncello Mojitos.

Plus, I have loads of mint growing on the side of my house so, I always have it on hand, at least during the warmer months.

The Mint Julep is traditionally served in a rocks glass or, ideally, in a frozen silver cup or julep cup but, if you have a copper Moscow mule mug, that’s work too.

Below, find out what is the best bourbon for your budget to make the best mint julep at home.

See my delicious Mint Julep recipe below but first, let’s talk about what to consider and which bourbon will suit your perfect mint julep for your tastes and budget.

What kind of Bourbon is best for a Mint Juelp?

Before delving into the specifics of bourbon selection, it’s essential to grasp what sets this whiskey apart. By law, bourbon must be made in the United States, primarily from a mash of at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak barrels.

This unique process presents a range of flavors, from caramel and vanilla to oak and spice, which makes bourbon a perfect foundation for different cocktails, especially Mint Julep Cocktails.

When selecting the ideal bourbon for your mint julep, some factors come into play:

Flavor: Do you prefer a sweeter, more caramel-forward bourbon, or do you lean towards one with spicy or oaky notes?
Proof: Bourbon comes in a range of proofs that indicate its alcohol content. Higher proof bourbons may make more intense flavors but can also be harsh, while lower proof options offer a smoother experience.
Budget: While there are exceptional bourbons at every price point, consider your budget when making your selection. Fortunately, there are plenty of affordable options that deliver taste and quality.

What are the Best Bourbons for a Mint Julep?

Woodford Reserve Bourbon

Woodford Reserve Bourbon is known for its balanced flavor profile and smooth finish. It’s a popular choice for mint juleps. Its notes of caramel, vanilla, and spice complement the refreshing mint and sugar in this classic cocktail.

Buffalo Trace

With its affordable price point and versatile flavor profile, Buffalo Trace is an excellent option for mint juleps. This bourbon contains notes of toffee, cinnamon, and oak, adding depth and complexity to your cocktail.

Maker’s Mark

Renowned for its signature red wax seal, Maker’s Mark is a wheated bourbon prized for its smoothness and sweetness. Its caramel and vanilla notes pair beautifully with the muddled fresh mint leaves and crushed ice in a mint julep.

Four Roses Single Barrel

For those seeking a more robust flavor profile, Four Roses Single Barrel delivers with its higher proof and complex palate. Notes of ripe fruit, spice, and oak make this bourbon a standout choice.

What is the official Bourbon of the Mint Julep?

Woodford Reserve is the best bourbon for a mint julep, which is considered the official drink of the Kentucky Derby because of its bold, oaky and fruity flavors that pair well with mint.

Ingredients

*The full, printable recipe is in the recipe card below.

Woodford Reserve Bourbon or your choice bourbon
simple syrup (more or less to taste)
fresh mint leaves
crushed ice (ice cubes will work too)

Instructions

First, muddle the fresh mint leaves in a 8-10 oz glass or frozen silver cup or similar sized glass.
Next, add the simple syrup and stir.
Then, add crushed ice to the glass.
Then, add your choice bourbon and stir well.
Last, garnish with fresh mint leaves.
Optional: add a splash of lime juice.

Homemade Simple Syrup

If you’re making a pitcher of mint juleps, you may want to make your own batch of fresh simple syrup. It’s easy to make with just water and white sugar.

Put in a small pot on your stove with equal parts water and sugar and bring to a slight boil, stir and turn off the heat. Let it cool before adding it to your drink.

Conclusion

Whether you prefer a sweeter bourbon or crave a bolder, more complex flavor profile, there’s a bourbon to suit your taste and budget. By selecting the right bourbon for your mint julep, you can make it to suit your desire for the perfect bourbon cocktail. Get your favorite bourbon, muddle some fresh mint leaves, and savor the refreshing delight of a perfectly crafted mint julep.

Cheers!